打电话给了CRA. 不用报个人所得税.讨论结束. -l123(Red Lily) @BC省华人论坛:BC省枫下论坛 The Rolia Forum of BC

枫下家园 / 枫下觅巢 /
tor
Toronto Area

经济给了佣金回扣，是支票，请问要不要报税？ -salara(salara); 2011-9-21 (#6933376@0)

No -daydream123(梦驰CN); 2011-9-21 (#6933435@0)
Ask your agent. Most likely yes. -jeffrey815(Smartiecat); 2011-9-21 (#6933476@0)

How much does your JJ know tax? Don't mislead others if you are not sure. -daydream123(梦驰CN); 2011-9-22 (#6936100@0)

The reason you need to ask your agent is 1. if your agent already pay the tax, you don't need to pay. 2. if your agent gives you cash back in the form of his pre-tax income, then you need to pay the tax. This is simple. -jeffrey815(Smartiecat); 2011-9-25 {137} (#6942458@0)
Unless the rebate is in the form of lower housing price, then both you and agent do not need to pay the tax as described below by others.

Please PM your JJ contact, thanks. -wbiao(Run Daddy Run); 2011-9-22 (#6934543@0)
常常看到大家说经纪给回扣支票，我买房的时候我的经纪且建议把回扣直接从房价上扣除，他说是他们公司的律师和会计师建议的，这样对大家都好，简单了很多。有一次买楼花也是这样操作的。 -xixiyim(Joy); 2011-9-22 (#6934614@0)

经纪给回扣是从经纪的佣金那里扣出来的，经纪人给多少就从房价上减多少，写在房屋买卖合同里有房价的那一页。 -xixiyim(Joy); 2011-9-22 (#6935639@0)

我买房子时jj也是这样说的,对他有什么好处不知道,他说对我可以少交土地转让税. -happygirl05(欣怡); 2011-9-22 (#6935577@0)

My agent told me that I do not have to report commission rebate cheque on my income tax return. -homeshopper(^-^); 2011-9-22 (#6935471@0)

Need to be clarify: Rebate is not income, it's discount on your payment, all from your after-tax income, that's why you don't need to claim for tax. Believe or not, your choice -daydream123(梦驰CN); 2011-9-22 (#6936093@0)

Absolutely not correct. The money given to the buyer is not commission rebate since the commission is from the seller not the buyer. It is actually the gift to the buyer and the agent will deduct it from his income as cost. -simoncowell(老评委); 2011-9-26 (#6943696@0)

How about Manufacture rebate? Did you even put it under tax? It's from the seller. -daydream123(梦驰CN); 2011-9-26 (#6944805@0)

金额比较高，超过1 万，以前也没跟JJ说报税的问题。JJ不肯给现金，不知有没有解决的方法。 -salara(salara); 2011-9-22 (#6935617@0)

You can transfer to me, so you don't need to worry about tax issue, I can take care of the tax. -daydream123(梦驰CN); 2011-9-22 (#6936097@0)

Could you please PM your agent contact info,? Thank you. -hchpbc(牛背上的小老鼠); 2011-9-22 (#6935694@0)
PM your jj contact if he dosen't mind, thx -littlecraw(海豚妈妈); 2011-9-25 (#6942708@0)
买卖房子还给回扣？看中国文化，到处渗透！看来不远的将来，要给回扣才缴税！ -roliagroup(roliagroup); 2011-9-26 (#6943388@0)

If the money is given back the people who pays you, it is the rebate. The commission given to the buyer is not rebate. It's gift. -simoncowell(老评委); 2011-9-26 (#6943707@0)

你说得对。给买方的钱不是rebate，而是gift。rebate是返钱给付你钱的人。中文“回扣”实际上有些贬义，和贿赂差不多。 -3x3(3x3); 2011-9-26 (#6943741@0)
A rebate is an amount paid by way of reduction, return, or refund on what has already been paid or contributed--- nothing to do with gift, who paid? the seller and the buyer. -abc2011(nonono); 2011-9-26 (#6943830@0)

In this case, the people who pays the commission is the seller's agent or the seller, not the buyer. -simoncowell(老评委); 2011-9-26 (#6943843@0)

有什么好争的？Rebate直接可以冲抵收入，也就是说收入1万元，rebate1千元，那么收入就是9千元；但给买家的回扣不能充抵收入，即收入1万元，回扣1千元，则收入还是1万元，但1千元可以计入成本销售费用。那收钱的买家应该有义务交税。 -hoboo(©); 2011-9-26 (#6944370@0)

付给买家未成年的孩子呢? 即使交税, 也少多了吧. -l123(Red Lily); 2011-9-26 (#6944806@0)
You may check with CRA, but the point here is you pay from your after-tax income, you already paid the tax. But CRA won't correct it if you include it into Income. Haha! -daydream123(梦驰CN); 2011-9-26 (#6944815@0)

You still don't get it. It's two different events. You purchase your house with your after-tax income. That is event 1 and it is completed. The seller agent gets commission from the seller. -jeffrey815(Smartiecat); 2011-9-27 {282} (#6945662@0)
And the seller's agent give buyer's agent 50% of the commission. These are all subject to tax. And this is Event 2. Then your agent gives you some commission back. The commission is subject to tax, so does commission back.

It's two separate events and you cannot combine them.

这么说是我错了？就应该给回扣？下次我去考经纪，收的佣金全部返还，权当为人民服务。我自己出油钱带你到处跑，下单，谈判，签合同，送文件。但好像也不对呀，好像还不如开出租车，车费之外，还可以拿小费。 -roliagroup(roliagroup); 2011-9-27 (#6945304@0)

Your JJ should tell you if the rebate is taxable or not. -realtor23(realtor23); 2011-9-27 (#6945593@0)

我那时候,经济让我自己选择,如果不报税的,那么钱少一点,我选择了保税的那个, 支票钱多点. 是经济挂靠的地产公司开的支票, 写的REFERRAL FEE. 事前经济还问我们写夫妻谁的名字好,少交点税. -newtoronto(一家四口); 2011-9-27 (#6945729@0)

@BC